Brainwriting ⇒ Effective Idea Generation

Brainwriting – At a Glace

Definition: Brainwriting is a written method of idea generation in which participants note down their suggestions, which are then expanded or further developed by others. This structured approach often leads to a high number of ideas generated within a short period.

Brainwriting Process: The method follows a defined sequence: topic definition, written idea collection, multiple rounds of idea passing, and a joint evaluation.

6-3-5 Method: Six people each write down three ideas and pass them along five times, generating a large number of ideas in one session.

Advantages: Brainwriting encourages equal participation, avoids speaking inhibitions, results in clearly formulated ideas, and enables reserved individuals to contribute.

Disadvantages: The process is more time-consuming than oral brainstorming, spontaneous creative impulses are less likely, and discussions about ideas are less immediate.

What Exactly is Brainwriting?

Brainwriting is a method for group-based idea generation. Unlike brainstorming, ideas are generated in writing rather than spoken aloud. Each participant writes their ideas on a sheet of paper and passes it to the next person. That person builds on the idea and adds a new one until everyone has seen and worked on all ideas.

In a business context, brainwriting can be an effective tool for idea generation. By exchanging ideas in writing, a group can collect a wide range of perspectives and thoughts.

Companies can use brainwriting to develop new products or services, solve problems or challenges, or further refine their strategies and align long-term goals more effectively.

Especially in strategic management and futures studies, brainwriting offers an effective way to identify and systematically develop innovative approaches at an early stage.

To ensure equal contribution, it is important that all participants write down their ideas independently and without predefined suggestions. Clear structuring and rules help make brainwriting more effective.

Structure of a Brainwriting Session

The structure of a brainwriting session follows a clear sequence that facilitates efficient idea generation. At the center are people with their unique personalities working together to find creative solutions.

This systematic idea collection can also be used in idea management to generate innovative input for future projects and strategic decisions.

Preparing the Brainwriting Session

At the beginning, the topic of idea generation is defined. A moderator explains the process and distributes the necessary materials such as forms, cards, or digital tools. It’s important that all participants understand their role and actively contribute.

Execution – Generating New Ideas

Each participant independently writes down their first ideas. This allows even reserved individuals to contribute without pressure. After a set time, the completed sheets are passed to the next person, who reads the previous suggestions and adds their own thoughts or enhancements.

Multiple Rounds

The process of passing and expanding on ideas continues until all participants have seen and worked on all ideas. This results in a comprehensive idea pool that combines diverse perspectives.

Final Evaluation

At the end of the session, all collected ideas are reviewed together. Duplicate suggestions are merged, and the most promising ideas are selected for further discussion.

Thanks to this structured approach, everyone can contribute regardless of personality. Brainwriting is particularly suitable for meetings where a wide range of alternative solutions is sought.

Difference from Brainstorming

Brainwriting and brainstorming are both group-based idea generation methods. Below is a comparison of the two:

Brainstorming Sessions:

Ideas are generated through verbal communication.

Everyone in the group speaks their ideas aloud, and others can respond or get inspired.

There are no limits on the number of ideas or time spent discussing them.

Brainwriting Method:

Participants write down their ideas and pass them on.

Each person builds on the ideas of others or adds new ones.

The process continues until all ideas have been read and worked on by everyone.

Overview of Brainwriting Methods

There are various brainwriting formats suited to different group sizes, goals, and settings. All methods aim to systematically gather and develop creative ideas while ensuring active participation from all involved.

Brainwriting is a valuable tool in innovation management for generating structured ideas for new products, services, or processes.

6-3-5 Method

The 6-3-5 method is a structured group creativity technique. Six participants each write three ideas on a form. In five additional rounds, the forms are passed on, allowing subsequent participants to expand or improve upon the ideas.

Group Brainwriting

All participants write their ideas simultaneously on a shared board or whiteboard. Others can then read and expand on these ideas. This method fosters spontaneous collaboration and inspires new perspectives.

Silent Brainwriting

Each person quietly writes down ideas on cards or slips of paper. These are then passed on and expanded by others. The quiet working environment prevents pressure and influence, ensuring everyone has a voice.

Online Brainwriting

A digital platform is used for submitting and commenting on ideas. Submissions are collected, made visible, and further developed in additional rounds. This method is ideal for distributed teams and remote work.

Round Robin Brainwriting

Each team member writes an idea on a sheet of paper, which is then passed around, so others can expand or improve it. This method ensures structured and balanced participation.

Benefits of Brainwriting

Brainwriting offers several advantages over other idea generation methods:

Everyone has equal opportunity to contribute ideas without interruptions or pressure, encouraging greater participation and creativity.

Writing leads to clearer, more precise ideas, enhancing their quality and comprehensibility.

Brainwriting promotes collaboration and idea exchange, as each participant builds on others’ ideas.

The written format allows for later review and further development, helping to refine the best ideas.

A larger number of ideas can be generated, as each participant records several ideas before passing them on.

Disadvantages of Brainwriting

Despite its advantages, brainwriting also has some drawbacks:

Brainwriting can be more time-consuming due to its written nature and the time needed to record ideas.

The creative spark might be lost, as spontaneous ideas are less likely to emerge than in verbal brainstorming.

Idea exchange can be slower since participants must wait to receive others’ input before contributing further.

Discussions may be more difficult, as the written format lacks the spontaneity and dynamic of oral conversations.

Frequently asked questions and answers

What is Brainwriting and an Example?

Brainwriting is a structured idea generation technique where participants write down their ideas individually and then pass them to others, who build on or add new ideas. Unlike brainstorming, it avoids interruptions and encourages equal participation.
For example, in a team of six, each member writes three ideas on a sheet, then passes it to the next person to add more ideas – this continues for several rounds to develop a wide range of solutions. This method is especially useful for generating ideas in a quiet, focused setting.

What is the Brainwriting Technique?

The brainwriting technique is a method for generating ideas in groups by having participants write down their thoughts instead of speaking them aloud. Ideas are passed around and expanded by others, allowing everyone to contribute equally without pressure. This technique helps avoid groupthink and often leads to a higher quantity and quality of ideas.

What is the 6-3-5 Brainwriting Technique?

The 6-3-5 brainwriting technique is a structured method where six participants each write down three ideas in five rounds. After writing, each person passes their sheet to the next participant, who builds on the existing ideas or adds new ones. This process generates up to 108 ideas in a short time and encourages diverse input from all group members.

What’s the Difference between Brainstorming and Brainwriting?

Traditional brainstorming sessions involve verbally sharing ideas in a group setting, where participants speak their thoughts aloud and build on each other’s input in real time. Brainwriting, on the other hand, is a written method where individuals record their ideas silently and pass them along for others to expand on. While traditional brainstorming is more spontaneous and interactive, brainwriting promotes equal participation and reduces the influence of dominant voices.

Sources

CreatingMinds.org: Brainwriting, URL: http://creatingminds.org/tools/brainwriting.htm letzter Zugriff: 27.03.2023

https://www.sciencedirect.com: “Brain-Writing Vs. Brainstorming Case Study For Power Engineering Education”, URL: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1877042815027123 letzter Zugriff: 27.03.2023

Harland Media: Kartenumlauftechnik, URL: http://www.innovationsmanagement.de/kreativitaetstechnik/kartenumlauftechnik.htm
letzter Zugriff: 27.03.2023

Mycoted: Brainwriting – Mycoted, URL: http://www.mycoted.com/Brainwriting letzter Zugriff: 27.03.2023

Pilkahn, Ulf (2007): Trends und Szenarien als Werkzeuge zur Strategieentwicklung, Erlangen

Julie S. Linsey & Blake Becker: “Effectiveness of Brainwriting Techniques: Comparing Nominal Groups to Real Teams”, URL: https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-0-85729-224-7_22 letzter Zugriff: 27.03.2023

Abdulfatai Owudunni: “Effect of Direct Attention Thinking Tools and Brainwriting Techniques on Creativity Skills of Workers”, URL: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/366958040_Effect_of_Direct_Attention_Thinking_Tools_and_Brainwriting_Techniques_on_Creativity_Skills_of_Workers letzter Zugriff: 27.03.2023